MasterChef SA Season 2 controversial final week: what lies ahead in episodes 27 and 28?

masterchef-sa-2-billboard-pete-goffe-woodNo matter what happens in the MasterChef SA Season Finale tomorrow evening, the choice of the Season 2 Masterchef SA winner will be controversial, if the outcry on Social Media about Kamini Pather being allowed through to Top 4 and Top 3 is anything to go by, even forcing M-Net to issue a media release about it!

Food blogger Kamini Pather was the clear leader until episode 24, rarely putting a foot wrong,  and only landing up in two Pressure Tests.  It is clear that her strength is creatively meeting cooking challenges, and that she is less good in having to replicate dishes of visiting chefs, which was her downfall in two episodes last week.  She is seen to be aloof, some seeing this as arrogance.  She was a winner of the bell, and Food and Wine Pairing Master Class at Nederburg, for the best Signature Sandwich in episode 5.  She was the joint winner with Tiron Eloff of the Coffee Invention Test in Ethiopia MasterChef 2 26 Kamini Whale Cottage Porfolioand received a MasterClass in the Jemma Valley. Went into her first (Vegetarian) Pressure Test due to the injera challenge in Ethiopia in episode 21. Into the Pressure Test in episode 24 for her poor month-end dish.  Poor performance in Gâteau Pressure Test, yet was (controversially) saved by the judges in episode 25.   Poor performance in Richard Carstens’ Chocolate Handkerchief dish in episode 26, yet was saved again. In a video interview after episode 26 a very tearful Kamini admits that her early morning yoga is ‘working less and less’, and that ‘the volume of tasks’ required when replicating dishes ‘is freaking me out’.  She has the highest number of votes from readers of our blog.

Sisters Landri and Seline van der Wat have won increasing viewer support, for their wonderful supportive relationship, for being smart, for their cooking skills (Seline for baking in particular), for how well-spoken they are, in often making commentary to the viewers in summing up special happenings, for being pretty, and for their warmth and support of the other contestants.

MasterChef 2 26 Leandri Whale Cottage PortfolioLeandri’s performance in the past 26 episodes has been as follows:  Had to go into Bouillabaisse Pressure Test in episode 8, and did very well. Was in the Spice Test in episode 10, but was allowed to join the other Finalists. Survived the Pressure Test against Amanda Beck at Castelli’s in Addis Ababa in episode 20. Did very well in Chef Prue Leith challenge to create a dish with iconic South African ingredients of a Michelin star quality in episode 23.  She has been in three Pressure Tests.  She has the second highest number of votes in our competition predicting who will win.

Seline has been in three Pressure Tests, but has had an amazing ability to bounce back when she has appeared to be at rock bottom! Into Pressure Test in episode 6.MasterChef 2 26 Seline Whale Cottage Portfolio Made a perfect hollandaise sauce, and was allowed to join the other Finalists in episode 6. Into Pressure Test in episode 8. Touch and go, but survived Bouillabaisse Test in episode 8.  Into Pressure Test in episode 25 for her poor month-end dish.

Leandri did so well in episode 26 in replicating Chef Richard Carstens’ Chocolate Handkerchief that she shot into the Finale for episode 28 on Wednesday evening. Seline will face Kamini in the cook out tonight, having to replicate a dish of The Test Kitchen Chef Luke Dale-Roberts, which Kamini may be weaker at again, disliking following recipes.

Going back to the MasterChef SA Facebook page, it is unbelievable to see how many negative comments are still being posted about Kamini having been allowed to progress into episodes 26 and 27, when she performed so poorly. Kamini is berated for not showing her passion for cooking (she has expressed that she wants to go into food media), that the program has ‘match fixing‘ and should now be called ‘MasterFix‘, a commentator even suggesting that the judges should read all the negative Facebook comments, not understanding that the filming was completed in March already!  Highly respected food blogger and radio presenter Nina Timm expressed herself strongly on the Facebook page in response to the media release which M-Net published in reaction to all the negative comments, 95 since the media release was posted on the Facebook page three days ago: ‘difficult to swallow this bull! For me it is not a personal issue, but rather a fail series! But while we are all debating and arguing the series gets publicity good or bad, it still is publicity’!  On Twitter the MasterChef SA stream is equally negative, the word ‘rigged‘ being mentioned regularly. It appears that many of the viewers would love to see a duel between the two sisters in the Finale.  One must commend M-Net for keeping the Facebook page open and for allowing all the negative comments, unlike Woolworths which closed its Facebook page for a couple of days last year when it was accused of racism in an employment advertisement. This is what M-Net issued as its media release:

As MasterChef South Africa starts to draw to a close, the competition is fiercer than ever. How do the Judges make the difficult decisions about who goes home, such as in this week’s back-to-back Pressure Tests?

The Pressure Test dish in Episode 26 (Wednesday, 4 September) was the most difficult and technically complex dish to date in the MasterChef competition. Chef Richard Carstens presented a dessert dish that had a number of elements on the same plate, and the Contestants had to replicate this dish as closely as possible, working from the same recipe.

According to MasterChef Judge Pete Goffe-Wood, tasting a dish of this nature requires specific judging procedures: “Judging plates with multiple elements, we have to assign a relative value to each of those elements i.e. their importance to the overall effect of the dish. It’s not simply a question of which contestant had the most elements correct, as some of those elements may just be garnish and not integral to the dish. It’s a question of having the core elements completed, and completed skillfully.” It was based on these criteria that the Judges unanimously decided that it was Ozzy’s turn to hang up his apron on Wednesday.

The MasterChef South Africa Judges are assigned their role in the series due to their professional expertise in the culinary field. For Pressure Tests, they are joined by special Guest Chefs – neutral figures and culinary experts – whose decisions are weighted evenly in the process of deciding who to eliminate.

Says Goffe-Wood, “We all believed, Richard Carstens included, that Kamini’s plate was a better replication of the most important elements on Richard’s challenging dish. In order for the competition to be fair we only ever judge the plate in front of us – no consideration is ever given to past performances. What makes MasterChef such a nail biting series is that Contestants live and die by their food on the day. We’ve emphasised this point throughout both Seasons. It was the toughest decision we’ve had to make so far, but with so few Contestants left, the margins for error become smaller and smaller.”

M-Net is in for a viewer outcry if Kamini is selected as the winner, which is the majority view, even if Leandri is quickly catching up as a winner favourite.   Having had a controversial Season 1 with the Restaurant prize being deemed to have been misleading, a controversial Season 2 winner outcome will not win M-Net any viewers for Season 3, which has been confirmed to be filmed later this year.

For an overview of what is lying ahead for the rest of Season 2 read here. For behind the scenes information on the filming of Season 2 in January read here.  For an overview of episode 1 of Season 2 read here. For an overview of episode 2 of Season 2 read here, for episode 3 read herefor episode 4 here, episode 5 here,  episode 6 here,  episode 7 episode 8episode 9, and episode 10,  episode 11,  episode 12 episode 13,  episode 14, episode 15, episode 16episode 17, episode 18 episode 19, episode 20,episode 21 episode 22, episode 23episode 24, and episode 25and episode 26 read here.  Enter our competition to predict which Finalist will win MasterChef SA Season 2.

POSTSCRIPT 10/9:  Gordon Ramsay was rumoured to be part of Season 2.  That would leave tomorrow’s last episode for his appearance!

POSTSCRIPT 12/9:  This MasterChef SA blogpost has attracted the most unbelievable readership, with close to 1000 unique readers today, the most read of all our MasterChef SA Season 2 stories.

POSTSCRIPT 14/9:  In an interview with Beeld, Kamini has admitted to knowing Chef Pete before MasterChef SA Season 2.  On her previous blog Deelishus she writes that she attended at least two courses at Chef Liam Tomlin’s Chef’s Warehouse and Cookery School, one in Cape Town and one in Franschhoek.

MasterChef SA, Season 2. Tuesdays and Wednesdays 19h30 – 20h30.  Twitter: @MasterChef_SA.

Chris von Ulmenstein, Whale Cottage Portfolio: Twitter: @WhaleCottage

13 replies on “MasterChef SA Season 2 controversial final week: what lies ahead in episodes 27 and 28?”

  1. Pieter says:

    It was rigged from the start,i would like to know where those three judges restaurants are and get viewers to boycott them! Season 3 will not be watched by my family, they should not even waste their time making another season! On this one the Aussies are way ahead of us!!!

    • Season 3 is on the cards already Pieter, and filming starts later this year. Chef Pete sells steak rolls at the Biscuit Mill and Bay Harbour markets on weekends, and he runs a cookery school ‘Kitchen Cowboys’ in Cape Town. His restaurant in Hout Bay closed down after a year. Chef Benny works for Tsogo Sun in Johannesburg. Chef Andrew works at Piccolo Mondo at The Michelangelo in Johannesburg.

    • Kerry Pieterson says:

      To be fair I don’t think it was the judges, I think it was pressure from the top. The judges were probably instructed to put her through. There is a bigger man behind the scenes that orchestrated it it has to be.

  2. Aman says:

    Wow. Your article seems to have a clear bias towards the sisters. Why not talk about how well Kamini did? What really made us roar with laughter was your clear biasness towards the sisters by saying “how well spoken they are”, haha…sorry I’m still laughing at your lack of writing skills. Are you serious? To a non South African like myself it is clear that you are using the racial card. I was told Kamini won. Enough said.

    • You are out of line here Aman. ‘Well spoken’ meant that they described events to the camera clearly (many contestants needed subtitles so that we could understand what they said), and therefore M-Net used them as ‘spokespersons’ regularly. There was no implication that Kamini was not understandable – she was far more reticent, distant, and aloof. Check the MasterChef SA Facebook page to see the outrage about the result! I have no bias – that is not my job as a writer. I have met Kamini in Cape Town, and do not know the Van der Wat sisters at all.

  3. sid says:

    And now it comes out that Kamini moved in the same food circles like Pete. They knew each other before MCSA.

    • The Cape Town food bloggers tend to know one another Sid. I cannot confirm whether they had met before, but it is likely. I used to run and Food & Wine Bloggers Club, which Kamini attended on occasion. Where did you see that Kamini and Pete know each other. Chef Pete should not have judged any of Kamini’s dishes if that was the case.

  4. Meyer says:

    The final few rounds of Masterchef should be judged by independent judges. When a Tsogo Sun event was advertised with Benny and Mamini as guests, more than a month before the final episode, the suspicion arose that Kamini was going to be the winner. Watching the final episodes knowing that she was probably the winner, it became obvious that the judges favoured her. The worst was her pasta dish … there is no ways that one could score more than say 5 out of 10 for such an unimaginative dish in the final cook-out. But the judges gave her good marks because it tasted good. I am sorry – it was simply not master chef stuff.

    • Good suggestion Meyer. I saw that publicity for the event too, and Jason was still a Cape Town Finalist at that stage. He could have been invited too. It was very clear to me too at that stage that Kamini had won!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.